The Afrocentric Fallacy



I seek to be like Spinoza and reveal the truth about Scripture and religion, and there by to undercut the political power exercised in modern states by religious authorities. People guided by fear, superstition and hope as their main emotions in a life devoted to the pursuit of temporal advantages, praying and worshipping, making votive offerings, sacrifice and engaging in all the various rituals of popular religion must realize that these are emotions that are as fleeting and the superstitions grounded in those emotions subject to fluctuations. Ambitious and self-serving clergy do their best to stabilize this situation and give some permanence to those beliefs and behaviors. “Immense efforts have been made to invest religion, true or false, with such pomp and ceremony that it can sustain any shock and constantly evoke the deepest reverence in all its worshippers”

Religious leaders are generally abetted in their purposes by the civil authority, which threatens to punish all deviations from theological orthodoxy as “sedition”. The result is a state religion that has no rational foundations. A close analysis of the Bible is particularly important for any argument because only a moral message alone lies in the sacredness of what is otherwise merely a human document. The Bible teaches only “obedience [to God]”, not knowledge. Thus, philosophy and religion, reason and faith, inhabit two distinct and exclusive spheres, and neither should tread in the domain of the other.

With an informed reading of the Scripture, a number of things become clear. First, the prophets were not men of exceptional intellectual talents, they were simply very pious, even morally superior individuals endowed with vivid imaginations. They were able to perceive God’s revelation through their imaginative faculties via words or real or imaginary figures. This is what allowed them to apprehend that which lies beyond the boundary of the intellect. The content of a prophecy varied according to the physical temperament, imaginative powers, and particular opinions or prejudices of the prophet. It follows that prophecy, while it has its origins in the power of God—and in this respect it is, in Spinoza’s metaphysical scheme, no different from any other natural event—does not provide privileged knowledge of natural or spiritual phenomena.

They should not be trusted when it comes to matters of the intellect, on questions of philosophy, history or science; and their pronouncements set no parameters on what should or should not be believed about the natural world on the basis of our rational faculties.

I’d also say this of many afrocentrists because black people and nations, similar to Spinoza’s Jews, did not surpass other nations in their wisdom or in their proximity to God. They were neither intellectually nor morally superior to other peoples. They were “chosen” only with respect to their social organization and political good fortune.

One of the problems that can arise form historical evidence is how words are interpreted. One example of that is the translation of the word “melanchroes” this word can mean black, or dark, or swarthy depending on who is translating it in G. C. Macaulay’s translation of Herodotus’s An Account of Egypt he translate the word as swarthy.

“So, when I had come to consider the matter I asked them both; and the Colchians had remembrance of the Egyptians more than the Egyptians of the Colchians; but the Egyptians said they believed that the Colchians were a portion of the army of Sesostris. That this was so I conjectured myself not only because they are dark-skinned and have curly hair (this of itself amounts to nothing, for there are other races which are so), but also still more because the Colchians, Egyptians, and Ethiopians alone of all the races of men have practised circumcision from the first[1].”

The word swarthy doesn’t mean black, necessarily. Because there are many examples of whites describing non-blacks as swarthy. Ben Franklin described Germans, Swedes and French people as swarthy

“The other objection that Ben Franklin had to German immigrants was their "swarthy complexion", which was an affront to the "purely white people" who originally settled America: Why should Pennsylvania, founded by the   English, become a Colony of Aliens, who will shortly be so numerous as   to Germanize us instead of our Anglifying them, and will never adopt our   Language or Customs, any more than they can acquire our Complexion. Which leads me to add one Remark: That the Number of purely   white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is   black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new   Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians,   French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call   a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only   excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People   on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were in-creased. And while   we are, as I may call it, Scouring our Planet, by clearing America of Woods, and so making this Side of our Globe reflect a   brighter Light to the Eyes of Inhabitants in Mars or Venus, why should   we in the Sight of Superior Beings, darken its People? Why increase the Sons of Africa, by Planting them in America, where we have so fair an   Opportunity, by excluding all Blacks and Tawneys, of increasing the lovely   White and Red? But perhaps I am partial to the Complexion of my Country, for   such Kind of Partiality is natural to Mankind[2].”

 

Ben Franklin made a clear distinction between African ‘black, tawny’ and German ‘swarthy’. Strabo goes a bit farther that Heroditus distinguishing between Ethiopians and Egyptians.

“The inhabitants of the south resemble the Ethiopians in colour, but their countenances and hair are like those of other people. Their hair does not curl, on account of the humidity of the atmosphere. The inhabitants of the north resemble the Egyptians[3].”

In this translation of the Odessey Homer uses the word melanchroiês[4] to describe Odysseus when Athena makes him young again.

“With this, Athene touched him with her golden wand. A well-washed cloak and tunic she first of all put about his breast, and she increased his stature and his youthful bloom. Once more he grew dark of color, and his cheeks filled out, and dark grew the beard about his chin[5].”

It’s difficult to apply racial terms as we know them to these words because they meant very different things. We should think of history diachronically not synchronically because the meaning of terms change. In their day Greeks would not have thought of themselves as white. And if we saw them then we probably wouldn’t have thought of them as white either. 

Herodotus could have meant the Egyptians were black he also could have meant that the Egyptians were dark-skinned similar to the Greeks it just depends on whose translating, but we do know that their word for dark could apply to literally anybody.

Also, while Egypt is an Arab country culturally genetically the story is a bit different. Studies on modern Egyptian DNA support the view that neither Egyptian Muslims nor Copts are Arab. All the invasions that Egypt has experienced over millennia, including the Arab invasion, do not seem to account for more than 15% of modern Egyptians' ancestry[6].  Egyptians are not genetically Arabs, but they may be so culturally and linguistically. This was once true, especially during the post-revolution years when Nasser's dreams of pan-Arabism were very much alive.

Today the Arab identity of Egypt has subsided among some Egyptian Muslims as it has around Egyptian Copts. Usually the term "Arabs" is used in reference to inhabitants of the Gulf states. Many Egyptians maintain a distinct Egyptian identity, and a strong sense of nationalism and patriotism.

It seems as though all ancient Egyptians probably weren't black. But they weren't white either, mind you. To presume that a culture has to be one or the other is to accept a racial dichotomy that white colonialists themselves invented for the purpose of sorting the world into "civilized" (white) and "savage" (colored) peoples. Most cultures in the world don't really fit neatly into either category: are Latinos white or colored? The answer depends partially on who's asking the question: most Latinos identify as white (both in the U.S. and Latin America) but most non-Latino Americans usually sort them as non-white.

‘White’ is essentially a byword for "European while ‘colored’ means non-white, so everyone else. These categories aren't static or they exist in a state of indicernability. In 19th century Europe, various ethnic groups were sometimes sorted into "more" or "less" white groups. According to many British anthropologists, the Irish were "less white" than the English. According to the Nazis, Slavic-speaking peoples like Poles or Russians were "subhuman" non-Aryans. Today, virtually all of these groups are considered "equally" white. This outdated way of talking about race was so prevalent and so dominant in academic circles that it's been accepted as largely accurate even by lots of non-white people. Instead of challenging the arbitrary lines in the sand 19th century racists drew up many simply flip the idea on its head, arguing that the roots of all civilization are inherently "black" rather than "white".

One may argue that because Egypt was invaded and conquered by so many different people, including the Libyans, Nubians, Canaanites, Mesopotamians, Persians, Greeks, Romans and the Arabs? Couldn't that have impacted the Egyptians' race? The answer is that conquest barely effects the genetic makeup of a country's populace before and after conquest.

Plus, there's also the fact that ancient Egyptians didn't really perceive themselves as either "black" or "white." In a painting from Pharaoh Seti I's tomb those with the palest skin are Libyans (Berbers), the next one over to the left are Nubians, followed by "Asiatics" (Mesopotamians). The bottom central group are Egyptians. By their own perception Egyptians were neither particularly dark nor particularly pale, and given their xenophobic attitude towards outside cultures (which was fairly common for most ancient peoples) they would probably resent being sorted into either "race[7]."

Now having said all of this I am going make a statement that makes it seem as though I am backtracking, but I am not. It can be ethically and historically correct to claim that many Egyptians, even the non-Nubian ones were black. The DNA evidence shows us that many people is the region of North Africa are not white or genetically Arab, by white I mean European. In deed much of Egypt is not genetically European or Arab. Much of the population of Egypt is native to Africa. Even if we take Herodotus with a grain of salt, Egyptians and Greeks were dark skinned people. In terms of race today they could fit under the category Black, but that’s only if we say that any dark skin makes one Black, which isn’t the case. There must have been a high amount of cultural diffusion between darker skinned Nubia Egyptian people as and less dark-skinned northern Egyptian people. Ostensibly both are Egyptian. We know that everyone in Egypt was dark-skinned northern Egyptians neither were they all Black, they definitely weren’t white or Arab.

 

Also I need to add that the people living in Egypt today are not exactly the same as the population of ancient Egypt. The population of ancient Egypt would have been much more mixed, with Nubians, Berbers, middle easterners and Europeans. Today, one can image that with Arabization and the uniformity that might come from that, Arabs possibly preferring to be around and do business with, and marry people who look them, i.e. Berbers.

 

One should also consider the racism of later Europeans are well. Europeans also, probably played a role in the discrimination of darker Egyptians and darker peoples generally form lighter Egyptians and Berbers and Arabs.

 

So is the population the same, I’d guess somewhat, the pieces are there, but they have been moved around and discriminated against.

 

This anachronism of back dating blackness, for anything but political purposes of undermining white supremacy, is ridiculous. Would an Ancient Greek or Roman, seeing the various shades of Egyptians and seeing them as intellectual equals have recognized the category blackness. Blackness exists because it is opposed to whiteness in the historical white supremacist narrative. Many Greeks and Romans saw the whiter-skinned Germanic races as backward. With this lens how could Any one conceive of whiteness. What we consider white today, (Europeans) were not united. Southern Europeans saw themselves as closer to Egyptians and Asians. They aren’t white either.

Blackness only came into being, in European discourse, around the Enlightenment, possibly before (Renaissance), I’m not really sure. Applying blackness past this time period is ahistorical because there was no whites to compare it to. However, for political purposes, of today. I think its fine to make to this ahistorical claim as long as the one making claim realizes the absurdity of the claim and it willing to respond to criticism with a biting remark like, “they weren’t white either!” or something else.

Nationality is often racialized. When we think of an Americans We might think of a pale white man. But there are so many different shades and ethnicities of even the white people in America. I don’t even have to mention black, indigenous, brown, east Asian Americans. Egyptians probably had a similar diffusion of skin tones of those with heavy Eurasian DNA. Arguable all Egyptians must have had various skin-tones, from dark brown, to light brown.

Also does what does black mean? I know this question is, and has been, addressed in a lot of literature but I still want to add my two cents. Are Austronesians Black. Some have claimed blackness as a part of their identity although I assume it was also applied to them by colonizers. If by Black we mean sub-Saharan then no, they are not black because they are not genetically similar. And if it’s the skin color there are people in India with very dark skin who are not black, there are also the descendants of people from sub-Saharan Africa as well, but the point is that skin color isn’t a good marker. One could say they have dark skin and they are from Africa. But as was said before some Indians have dark-skin and there are whites south Africans who can trace there ancestry several hundred thousand years back to Africa? They are African but they are not black. Abdominals who claim blackness are not African but they can be considered black in a political sense.

The more we move away from Race as purely some phenotype the more inclusive blackness can be.



[1] https://www.gutenberg.org/files/2131/2131-h/2131-h.htm

[2] https://www.dialoginternational.com/dialog_international/2008/02/ben-franklin-on.html

[3] https://www.gutenberg.org/files/44886/44886-h/44886-h.htm

[4] I also tried to pull these translations myself, they suck, but they could be relevant.

Greek to English to Greek- μελαγχροιὴς γένετο, γναθμοὶ δὲ τάνυσθεν, κυάνεαι δ᾿ ἐγένοντο - a dark-skinned man, jaw-dropping, the blue was rising – melanchroiís géneto, gnathmoí dé tánysthen, kyáneai d᾿ egénonto ένα σκοτεινό πρόσωπο éna skoteinó prósopo.

Greek to Greek to English- μελαγχροιὴς – melanchroiís – swarthy, dark.

[5] https://www.loebclassics.com/view/homer-odyssey/1919/pb_LCL105.131.xml

[6] https://www.gutenberg.org/files/44886/44886-h/44886-h.htm

[7] https://observationdeck.kinja.com/no-egyptians-arent-white-but-they-arent-black-eithe-1665322870

 


Comments

Popular Posts